S.1377 Advances Through the House Natural Resources Committee — But Our Work Is Far From Over

chwildhorseadvocates Avatar

Before I share yesterday’s legislative update, I want to begin with some words from Theodore Roosevelt himself.

In 1910, Roosevelt delivered a speech that became famous for a passage known as The Man in the Arena.

Those words have taken on a very personal meaning for me.

Over the last four years, there have been plenty of moments when we’ve stumbled, when things didn’t go as planned, and when the challenges seemed overwhelming.

There have been disappointments, frustrations, and more than a few tears.

But we kept showing up.

We kept fighting for something we believed in.

And while we still have work to do, I think we’ve earned the right to take a moment and recognize just how far we’ve come.

We entered the arena. We stayed in the arena. And we dared greatly.

“It is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood; who strives valiantly; who errs, and comes short again and again, because there is no effort without error and shortcoming; but who does actually strive to do the deeds; who knows the great enthusiasms, the great devotions; who spends himself in a worthy cause; who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who know neither victory nor defeat.”

~ Theodore Roosevelt, “Citizenship in a Republic,” April 23, 1910

Hello and Happy Thursday!

Yesterday marked another significant milestone in the effort to secure federal protection for the historic wild horses of Theodore Roosevelt National Park.

On Wednesday, November 18, the House Natural Resources Committee favorably reported S.1377, the Theodore Roosevelt National Park Wild Horse Protection Act, by unanimous consent.

This is an important step forward in the legislative process.

But before we go any further, I want to make something very clear.

CHWHA’s position on S.1377 has NOT changed.

Since the legislation was introduced in April 2025, we have consistently expressed our appreciation for Senator Hoeven’s efforts to provide federal protection for these horses while also making it clear that we cannot support the legislation as written without the amendments we believe are necessary.

We have spent the last year and a half advocating for those changes.

While yesterday’s committee action represents significant progress, it does not resolve the concerns we’ve been raising.

Our goal has never been simply to get legislation passed. Our goal is meaningful, lasting protection for the existing historic wild horse herd at Theodore Roosevelt National Park.

Where Does S.1377 Stand?

Here’s a quick look at the legislation’s progress:

  • April 2025: S.1377 was introduced in the U.S. Senate.
  • June 2026: S.1377 passed the Senate.
  • November 18, 2026: The House Natural Resources Committee favorably reported S.1377 by unanimous consent.

The next step is consideration by the full U.S. House of Representatives.

A House vote is not automatic, and we don’t yet know when one might be scheduled.

If the House passes the same version already approved by the Senate, the legislation can be sent to the President for signature. If changes are made, both chambers must agree on identical language first.

We’ve come a long way, but we’re not at the finish line yet.

What Has CHWHA Been Doing Behind the Scenes?

Much of our advocacy surrounding S.1377 has been different from the highly visible work we did in 2023 and 2024 to stop the National Park Service’s plan to eliminate the horses.

Over the past year and a half, we’ve spent considerable time communicating with congressional offices, attending meetings, sharing information about the horses, and advocating for amendments.

Throughout the summer and fall, we also communicated with members and staff from both political parties on the House Natural Resources Committee.

Our concerns have remained consistent since April 2025.

We have requested:

  • A population range of 150–200 horses.
  • Genetic viability and explicit protection of the existing historic herd and its bloodlines.
  • Responsible fertility control, including monitoring and transparency surrounding GonaCon use.
  • A formal working group involving qualified experts and stakeholders.
  • A comprehensive management plan with appropriate environmental review, public participation, and periodic updates.

These are protections we believe are essential to the long-term future of the herd.

On Monday, we learned not only about the upcoming committee markup, but also that the amendments we’d been requesting would not be accepted.

That was disappointing.

But rather than simply accepting that there was nothing more we could do, we continued communicating with congressional staff.

And that persistence led to an unexpected opportunity for our concerns to be heard, even if it wasn’t quite the outcome we had originally hoped for.

An Unexpected Opportunity: Additional Views

Earlier this week, CHWHA was invited by a congressional staff member to submit the concerns we wanted addressed in the Additional Views being prepared for Democratic members of the House Natural Resources Committee.

We immediately submitted our concerns, focusing on the need for meaningful protection of the historic herd, genetic viability, responsible fertility control, transparency, and accountable management.

We received confirmation that the substance of CHWHA’s concerns would be incorporated into the Additional Views being prepared for committee members.

What exactly does that mean?

When congressional committees consider legislation, committee members can submit Additional Views expressing concerns or recommendations related to a bill.

Because Democrats are currently the minority party on the House Natural Resources Committee, Additional Views provide an opportunity for their members to formally document concerns or recommendations about legislation that has advanced through the committee.

If included in the published committee report, those views become part of the official congressional record associated with the legislation.

Additional Views do not change the legislation or create legally binding requirements for the National Park Service.

However, they can document important concerns and provide a reference for future congressional oversight and discussions about how the law is implemented.

For CHWHA, that could be significant.

After more than a year of advocating for stronger protections, we were specifically invited to submit our concerns for consideration in those Additional Views.

And we were subsequently told that the substance of those concerns would be incorporated.

That tells us something important: Our concerns were heard.

It doesn’t mean we secured the amendments we requested, and it doesn’t guarantee those protections will become law.

But it does mean our efforts to raise these issues reached congressional staff who were willing to help bring them into the committee’s reporting process.

We have not yet seen the final Additional Views, so we cannot confirm exactly which of our concerns will appear or how they will be addressed.

We’ll share that information when the official committee report becomes available.

Looking at the Bigger Picture

On Monday evening, I also had a conversation with one of our North Dakota state legislators about S.1377 and the upcoming committee markup.

As we discussed the legislation and the concerns we’ve continued raising, he said something that really made me think.

“Chris, take a moment to realize what you have accomplished. It’s monumental.”

He went on to tell me that not many people manage to take legislation as far as we have, especially at the federal level.

I have to admit, sometimes I get so focused on everything that still needs to be done that I forget to appreciate how far we’ve come.

His words reminded me to look at the bigger picture.

In December 2022, the National Park Service proposed eliminating the wild horses from Theodore Roosevelt National Park.

In April 2024, we celebrated the announcement that the agency was no longer pursuing that proposal.

And now, in November 2026, federal legislation intended to protect these horses has passed the Senate and cleared the House Natural Resources Committee.

That is significant progress, and it deserves to be recognized.

I also want to take a moment to acknowledge Senator Hoeven and his staff for their continued efforts to move S.1377 forward.

While CHWHA has been clear about the amendments we believe are necessary, we also recognize the considerable work that has gone into bringing this legislation to this point.

We sincerely appreciate those efforts, as well as the opportunities we’ve had to meet with his staff and share our concerns.

We can be grateful for the progress that’s been made while continuing to advocate for the protections we believe are still needed.

We have never believed that bad legislation is better than no legislation. And we have never believed that getting a bill passed should matter more than getting the protections right.

We can appreciate this milestone without changing our position on S.1377.

And that’s exactly what we’re doing.

What Happens Next?

We’ll continue monitoring S.1377 as it moves through the legislative process, including any opportunity for consideration by the full House.

We’re also waiting for the official committee report to see how our concerns are reflected in the Additional Views.

And regardless of whether S.1377 becomes law, CHWHA will continue advocating for responsible management, transparency, and meaningful protection of the historic wild horse herd.

I also want to thank everyone who has been part of this effort.

Whether you’ve contacted your elected officials, mailed postcards, shared information, made a donation, or helped others understand why these horses matter, you’ve contributed to the progress we’ve made.

We should be proud of how far we’ve come.

And we HAVE to be just as committed to the work that still lies ahead.

Because passing legislation isn’t the finish line.

Meaningful, lasting protection for these horses is the goal.

And that commitment isn’t going to change.


Help Us Continue This Important Work!

Your support helps CHWHA continue advocating for the lasting protection of the historic wild horses of Theodore Roosevelt National Park.

Click the logo below to make a donation. Donations can also be made through PayPal here: https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=XNYNCNVLTULGC

Leave a Reply